The disappearance of Naomi Huyard sends shockwaves through her small community, and a disturbing discovery by detectives reveals that there's more to her story than initially meets the eye.
Aired: Oct 5, 2019The sudden confession of Anna Borntregger's husband to the police, claiming h...
Aired: Oct 5, 2019A young boy's body is discovered beside a rural highway, sparking a two-year ...
Aired: Oct 5, 2019A brutal murder shatters the peaceful Amish community, revealing a sinister r...
Aired: Oct 12, 2019The disappearance of Naomi Huyard sends shockwaves through her small communit...
5. The Original Amish Murderer
Aired: Oct 12, 2019A gruesome murder rocks the tight-knit Amish community, as Katie Gingerich is...
Aired: Oct 12, 2019A Mennonite family man's DUI stop uncovers a web of organized crime, putting ...
