Mary Bogue was born to Nelson Binner and Gladys Witt, her parents hailing from upstate New York, and was the fourth of five siblings. Her passion for acting was evident from a young age, as she would often act out imagined scenes in the second-story hallway of their home on Division Street.
In 1959, the family relocated to California, which only further fueled her desire to perform. She soon landed a role in Beauty and the Beast, a children's production at The Old Globe Theatre in San Diego. This marked the beginning of her involvement in junior and high school productions, where she continued to hone her craft.
However, when she ventured out on her own in the early 1970s, she found that success wasn't as easily attainable as she had hoped. Her first audition was particularly memorable, as the "casting director" expected nudity, leaving her feeling discouraged and hesitant to pursue her dream for many years.
It wasn't until 1990 that Mary Bogue returned to her first love, albeit at a slow pace, as she was also dedicating her time to caring for 16 foster daughters. It wasn't until she was cast in Antonio Banderas' directorial debut, Crazy in Alabama (1999),although she was ultimately cut from the final production, that she found the motivation to pursue her acting career once again.