Jerry's fascination with music began when he received a bass guitar as a Christmas gift during his high school days. This newfound passion led him to cross paths with his friend Manny, who would later introduce him to the legendary Glenn Danzig. As their friendship blossomed, Glenn extended an invitation to Jerry to join his emerging band, The Misfits, as the bassist. Jerry's tenure with The Misfits spanned from 1977 to 1983, a period marked by the band's steady growth and eventual disbandment.
Notably, Glenn Danzig's songwriting prowess was the backbone of The Misfits' discography, with Jerry contributing his own unique flair as the band's bassist. However, Jerry's creative aspirations soon led him to pursue a new musical venture, teaming up with his brother Doyle (formerly known as Paul Caiafa, who joined The Misfits from 1980 to 1983) to form a Christian metal band called Kryst The Conqueror. The duo adopted the stage names Mo The Great and Jerry, respectively, as they embarked on this new musical journey.
Fast-forwarding to 1994, Jerry's perseverance ultimately led to a significant victory in the lawsuit he had filed against Glenn Danzig. This triumph allowed Jerry to reclaim the rights to perform under the iconic name The Misfits. With renewed creative energy, Jerry recruited Michale Graves, an aspiring vocalist who was unfamiliar with The Misfits' legacy, as well as Dr. Chud, a drummer from New Jersey, to join the revamped lineup. By this point, The Misfits had evolved into one of the most influential and successful punk bands of all time.